Why thinking positive can make things worse

and what you can do instead to create the change you want

That’s right, I said that positive thinking can, and often does, make things worse.  Why?  Because when you “try” to think positively it doesn’t work, mainly because of the “try”.  When it doesn’t work you will feel ashamed and insecure about the fact that you are doing it wrong.

So, if thinking positive doesn’t work, why are people telling you to think positive and what exactly do people mean by it? 

Make ME more comfortable

Some people don’t know what they mean.  They just want the uncomfortable emotions that you have to go away because your emotions are, well, uncomfortable.  However, pretending that you are happy will only make you numb to your emotions.  That’s not healthy, that’s called apathy and depression.  People have emotions; the fun ones and the not so fun ones. Learning to sit with, and allow, ALL of your emotions and excavating lessons from them is a skill.

But that’s a blog post of it’s own.

It’s really not that bad

Some people want you to take your circumstances, imagine how they could be worse and then be grateful for the circumstances you have.  This can be helpful sometimes, as it can kick you into a more objective frame of mind and can allow you to turn the circumstance into something manageable.  That said, more often than not, it only brings shame to your struggling.  Now you feel like you shouldn’t feel the way you do because others actually have real problems and you don’t. 

Not helpful.

Master of the Universe

And still others want you to use language that reflects a positive outlook on life;

  • Look in the mirror and love yourself,
  • Use your thoughts to create the things you want. 
  • Imagine that you are in control. 
  • What do you want?  (Future creation)
  • If you think positively it will come. 

I’m not saying this is necessarily wrong. It’s the whole point of perspective change. That said, it’s not the first step.  If you merely change the language in your head or the words you speak, more often than not, your mind will counter the conscious purposeful thoughts. 

You might practice saying, “I love myself!” in the mirror every morning.  While you are making the effort of change, in the back of your mind you hear, “I hate my fat belly.  If I’m so great, why am I poor? Why can’t I do anything right? I’m lazy, ugly, and nothing will ever work out for me.” 

Do you think the positive thought is going to win against all of the counter arguments against it?  Definitely not!

So, if thinking positive isn’t the answer, what is?

It all starts with awareness 

You need to listen to the thoughts that are already there and recognize which ones you actually believe.  It’s not what you say or what anyone else says, for that matter. It’s what YOU actually believe to be true.     

Belief is EVERYTHING.  None of the words matter if you won’t believe the truth of them.  The funny thing is, most of the thoughts in your head are subjective.  Whatever you choose to believe, is truth!  No matter what you believe, you will find situations and facts to support those beliefs about yourself and/or your circumstances.  You even have the power to take facts and then make meanings around the facts that are subjective.  You can make a fact good, bad or simply a fact. 

It’s the meanings you believe and justify that actually create how you behave in the world and you will seek out circumstances that more fully justify your beliefs.  The world is all things, it’s evil, wonderful, a playground, a warzone, a game, a…  You, a long time ago, chose one overarching belief and ran with it.  What is your belief about the world? That’s always a good place to start.
Time to get curious.

So what do you do?

The first thing you need to address is what thought are you choosing to believe. Recognize the story you are telling yourself, and the underlying belief that makes your story true, for you. Then you must show yourself some compassion for that belief, whatever it is. Hell, even celebrate because it’s super hard to dig though your thoughts and find the belief that makes your story real.

What’s after that? Work. You have to embrace the slow process of separating fact from story and then you must decide if the underlying belief is making you more empowered and motivated or shutdown and fearful. If the belief isn’t helpful, search for instances that prove your belief wrong. This is the most powerful work you can do for yourself. And it’s the hardest work because it’s uncomfortable to be wrong.

Breathe into being ok with being wrong as you grow your new belief.

If you choose to make this work a daily practice you CAN think positive, believe it, and change your life.

The Thrive Global Community welcomes voices from many spheres. We publish pieces written by outside contributors with a wide range of opinions, which don’t necessarily reflect our own. Learn more or join us as a community member!
Share your comments below. Please read our commenting guidelines before posting. If you have a concern about a comment, report it here.

You might also like...


I’m a psychologist, but I don’t always think positively, and I don’t think you need to either!

by Brooke Wachtler, Psy.D.
PeopleImages/Getty Images

A 5-Step Plan to Help You Overcome Your Biggest Fears in Life

by Mareo McCracken

Are Your Thoughts Really The Cause Of Your Problems?

by Sally Ella Horn

Sign up for the Thrive Global newsletter

Will be used in accordance with our privacy policy.

Thrive Global
People look for retreats for themselves, in the country, by the coast, or in the hills . . . There is nowhere that a person can find a more peaceful and trouble-free retreat than in his own mind. . . . So constantly give yourself this retreat, and renew yourself.


We use cookies on our site to give you the best experience possible. By continuing to browse the site, you agree to this use. For more information on how we use cookies, see our Privacy Policy.