Thrive on Campus//

Different Ways to Lead

By teaching extroverted leadership as the standard, business schools do its students a disservice.

LinkedIn Sales Navigator/Unsplash
LinkedIn Sales Navigator/Unsplash

Welcome to our new section, Thrive on Campus, devoted to covering the urgent issue of mental health among college and university students from all angles. If you are a college student, we invite you to apply to be an Editor-at-Large, or to simply contribute (please tag your pieces ThriveOnCampus.) We welcome faculty, clinicians, and graduates to contribute as well. Read more here.

Over the summer, I found myself sneaking away from my open plan workspace at my internship, to a quiet green room, with cubicles and large windows. I found that I did better work there than at my desk, surrounded by imagined gazes. Last week too, I left a school party, giddy with excitement, not from the music, but from the thought of going home to my bed and a good book. In class, I sometimes rehearse my comments before I voice them, moving words around in my head till they sound right and accurately convey the message I want to pass across. Many times, by the time this happens, the conversation has moved in a different direction, and I quickly abandon my comment, refusing to speak merely for the sake of it, or waste words, as I often think of it.

I am an introvert. Not shy, just an introvert. Susan Cain will tell you there’s a difference. And I agree. My deliberation over classroom comments isn’t because I’m scared of saying the wrong thing. I’m in school to learn, after all. Neither is my joy at burying my nose in a book from fear of talking to my peers. I simply believe that words spoken should add value and besides, between imagined worlds in books and the ones in my head, I keep myself pretty good company.

Many of our greatest inventors and leaders are, or were, introverts: Albert Einstein, Rosa Parks, Bill Gates, Warren Buffett, Eleanor Roosevelt, Elon Musk, Steve Wozniak, Barack Obama. Yet, in the year and a half I have spent at business school, the standard for leadership that has often been portrayed is one of extroversion. Students are advised to be assertive, to “walk the factory floors,” to have the kind of ostentatious personality that makes itself known as soon as it enters a room. And these are undoubtedly necessary leadership skills to cultivate, especially for certain circumstances. My problem is not that this narrative is incorrect, but rather that it is incomplete.

Little emphasis is placed on showing how introversion in leadership is beneficial. The CEO Genome Study, a 10-year study of distinguishing attributes of high-performing CEOs, for instance, found that introverts, more often than extroverts, outperform board and investor expectations, although the latter are often boards’ favored choices. Why then don’t business schools teach that introversion can make for great leadership and encourage all students — introverted or not — to cultivate these winning skills? The same CEO study also found that high confidence levels were not correlated with high performance, so why do business schools, and society in general really, idolize this performance of self?

Introverted leaders are observant, listen effectively, and create an environment where good ideas, regardless of source, are welcome. Research by Adam Grant and colleagues found that, especially in times of change and with proactive workers, introverted leaders are often more effective and yield higher profits than their extroverted counterparts. Solitude nurtures deep thought, which in the best case, blossoms into genius and in the worst, into profound self-awareness, characteristics that would make for a remarkable leader. Yet, business school classes very rarely stress solitude, or explicitly connect its fruits to introversion.

As a result, introverted students are often left questioning their place in halls lined with pictures of leaders that have changed the world. Words like “introversion” or “quiet” never show up next to these pictures. As they watch their peers jump effortlessly from networking event to house party, many are left feeling that they need to change who they are, or risk wasting their business school experience. With known examples of introverts in leadership positions, and clear benefits of introverted leadership, business schools do all their students — introverts, ambiverts, and extroverts — a disservice by painting an incomplete picture of leadership. In an age where diversity is a main focus, schools must examine ways of fostering said diversity that go beyond the usual categories.

In diversifying leadership portrayals, I propose three lines of action. 

  • First, business schools much teach that introverted leaders exist. They should diversify the leadership characteristics highlighted in cases; choose cases that show introversion in leadership as having merit, with lessons that extroverts can — and should — learn from. Whether through explicit or subliminal messaging, schools should give students permission to be themselves, wherever they fall on the psychological spectrum. Where edits to self are encouraged, the burden should be as heavy on the extrovert as on the introvert.
  • Second, schools should show that what they teach is real — that there are living examples of introverted leaders. Bring them to fireside chats, as classroom speakers, send students to their companies.
  • Third, craft a learning and living environment that caters to both introverts and extroverts. Encourage both individual and group thought. Create spaces in which students that need it can find solitude in the midst of the bustle. Open-plan standing desks and quiet green rooms, with cubicles and large windows, both belong in our business schools. 

The prevailing stereotype of the typical business school student is a charismatic, larger-than-life, sometimes brash party animal. But real life is often more complex. People across the psychological spectrum exist at business school, and in executive suites around the world. Business schools need to give this reality more thought.

Subscribe here for all the latest news on how you can keep Thriving.

More on Mental Health on Campus:

What Campus Mental Health Centers Are Doing to Keep Up With Student Need

If You’re a Student Who’s Struggling With Mental Health, These 7 Tips Will Help

The Hidden Stress of RAs in the Student Mental Health Crisis

The Thrive Global Community welcomes voices from many spheres. We publish pieces written by outside contributors with a wide range of opinions, which don’t necessarily reflect our own. Learn more or join us as a community member!
Share your comments below. Please read our commenting guidelines before posting. If you have a concern about a comment, report it here.

You might also like...

Thrive on Campus//

Get Out of Bed, and Go to Class

by Isabelle Gillman
Thrive on Campus//

Transferring is More Than Just Switching Locations

by Angela Peterson
Courtesy of LinkedIn Sales Navigator / Unsplash
Thrive on Campus//

How to Talk to Your Professors About Your Mental Health

by Active Minds

Sign up for the Thrive Global newsletter

Will be used in accordance with our privacy policy.

Thrive Global
People look for retreats for themselves, in the country, by the coast, or in the hills . . . There is nowhere that a person can find a more peaceful and trouble-free retreat than in his own mind. . . . So constantly give yourself this retreat, and renew yourself.

- MARCUS AURELIUS

We use cookies on our site to give you the best experience possible. By continuing to browse the site, you agree to this use. For more information on how we use cookies, see our Privacy Policy.